From: Dennis on
How do you reconcile Luke Chapter 3 which gives 76 generations from
Adam to Jesus making a maximum of 4000 years, with 'Mitochondrial Eve'
living in Africa 150,000 years ago ? Y-chromosome research also puts
Adam way back before any conceivable Bible date. Modern man reached
Australia 60,000 years ago, after leaving Africa. How do you propose
to square the circle, Alistair ?
From: HeyBub on
Dennis wrote:
> How do you reconcile Luke Chapter 3 which gives 76 generations from
> Adam to Jesus making a maximum of 4000 years, with 'Mitochondrial Eve'
> living in Africa 150,000 years ago ? Y-chromosome research also puts
> Adam way back before any conceivable Bible date. Modern man reached
> Australia 60,000 years ago, after leaving Africa. How do you propose
> to square the circle, Alistair ?

How do you square the receipe for pumpkin pie with the instructions for
taking cel-phone video pictures?

The answer to both questions is: you can't. You can't because the narratives
talk about two different things to two different audiences at two different
times.

Here's a more relevant example:

Why do introductory college Physics courses start with Newtonian mechanics
when everyone knows that Quantum Mechanics has more "truthiness" and string
theory may even be truthier?

What do you think would happen if a missionary to a Cargo Cult tribe began
his proselytizing with a lecture on mitochondrial DNA? He'd get eaten,
that's what!

One explains at the hearer's ability to comprehend.


From: Anonymous on
In article <72551ff7-21ea-48bc-9205-d9f4b6a6a7da(a)p69g2000hsa.googlegroups.com>,
Dennis <dgoffin(a)ntlworld.com> wrote:
>How do you reconcile Luke Chapter 3 which gives 76 generations from
>Adam to Jesus making a maximum of 4000 years, with 'Mitochondrial Eve'
>living in Africa 150,000 years ago ?

The same way that one usually reconciles a religion with a science... or
maybe in a slightly different manner.

DD
From: Joel C. Ewing on
docdwarf(a)panix.com wrote:
> In article <72551ff7-21ea-48bc-9205-d9f4b6a6a7da(a)p69g2000hsa.googlegroups.com>,
> Dennis <dgoffin(a)ntlworld.com> wrote:
>> How do you reconcile Luke Chapter 3 which gives 76 generations from
>> Adam to Jesus making a maximum of 4000 years, with 'Mitochondrial Eve'
>> living in Africa 150,000 years ago ?
>
> The same way that one usually reconciles a religion with a science... or
> maybe in a slightly different manner.
>
> DD

For those whose concept of ultimate truth is locked to a specific
literal interpretation of the Bible, obviously when God created the
universe several thousand years ago, he must have created it with all
the "false" evidence that misleads man into thinking the universe is
billions of years old.

Or did God really create the universe yesterday and just give us
fabricated memories, a fabricated environment, and a fabricated history
to falsely convince us of a prior existence?

Once one allows for the possibility that a capricious, creator God might
have fabricated false historical evidence to confuse us, there is no
logical reason to assume that anything we think we "know" about the past
is above suspicion. While being mindful that history consistently shows
that each generation's understanding of physical reality is imperfect,
either the world has always been governed by the same physical laws and
processes we can observe today and the Bible interpreted in the light of
that reality, or all bets are off.

To make this post at least marginally on topic, perhaps COBOL didn't
exist until yesterday when the universe was created, and Grace Hopper is
just one of many false memories to explain why God created all those
business COBOL programs as part of creation!

--
Joel C. Ewing, Fort Smith, AR jREMOVEcCAPSewing(a)acm.org
From: Anonymous on
In article <13pqqiih2brk83c(a)corp.supernews.com>,
Joel C. Ewing <jcREMOVEewing(a)CAPS.acm.org> wrote:
>docdwarf(a)panix.com wrote:
>> In article
><72551ff7-21ea-48bc-9205-d9f4b6a6a7da(a)p69g2000hsa.googlegroups.com>,
>> Dennis <dgoffin(a)ntlworld.com> wrote:
>>> How do you reconcile Luke Chapter 3 which gives 76 generations from
>>> Adam to Jesus making a maximum of 4000 years, with 'Mitochondrial Eve'
>>> living in Africa 150,000 years ago ?
>>
>> The same way that one usually reconciles a religion with a science... or
>> maybe in a slightly different manner.
>
>For those whose concept of ultimate truth is locked to a specific
>literal interpretation of the Bible, obviously when God created the
>universe several thousand years ago, he must have created it with all
>the "false" evidence that misleads man into thinking the universe is
>billions of years old.

That might be for someone else to consider, Mr Ewing... but the posting
asked 'how do you' and I answered with how I did so.

DD