App that seperates audio
in [Cakewalk]
|
Prev: Pagefile
Next: EZ Ringtone
From: Michael on 11 Apr 2008 02:35 AKA gray asphalt wrote: > "Steve L." <email(a)myeamail.com> wrote in message > news:Xns9A7CCF6407CE5emailmemyemailcom(a)66.133.129.71... >> "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> thought it was ok to ask >> >>> It would be so cool to hear them over and over with >>> different instrumentation. >>> >> >> MIDI score ? then it would be relatively easy. > > That would be cool. No mp3s. Yikes!!! You'd better be starting from pretty friggin' fine-quality compressed audio if you're after decent per-instrument audio extraction from it (when it's possible - and that isn't far ahead at all).
From: Steve L. on 11 Apr 2008 07:55 "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> thought it was ok to ask > > "Steve L." <email(a)myeamail.com> wrote in message > news:Xns9A7CCF6407CE5emailmemyemailcom(a)66.133.129.71... >> "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> thought it was ok to ask >> >>> It would be so cool to hear them over and over with >>> different instrumentation. >>> >> >> MIDI score ? then it would be relatively easy. > > That would be cool. No mp3s. I was going to add the > replaced parts with midi ie. soft synths ... is that what > dimension pro is called? > > I don't use dimensionPro .. I'm wondering you couldn't obtain a MIDI score and just plug your samples into it. I think that would be the road i'de explore first.
From: malachi on 11 Apr 2008 09:23 "Ricky Hunt" <rhunt22(a)hotmail.com> wrote in message news:WoCLj.61745$TT4.30611(a)attbi_s22... > "Steve L." <email(a)myeamail.com> wrote in message > news:Xns9A7CCF2ED2B12emailmemyemailcom(a)66.133.129.71... >> "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> thought it was ok to ask >> > Sadly the majority still seem to be used for turd polish instead of > getting it right on the front end. > Ah yes, turd polish. That's in aisle 6 next to the left handed smoke shifters and the jumbo shrimp. malachi
From: Max Arwood on 11 Apr 2008 11:02 Midi is the only way to go. The melodyne thing will be years before it will work well enough to do "real" work. I would be surprised if it could even extract an oboe part from a woodwind quintet. BIAB does a fair job extracting the chords from an mp3 in a pop style, don't think it would work with a classical piece. Here are a few midi's to play with: http://www.virtualsheetmusic.com/MIDI/Albinoni/AlbinoniOb3/01Allegro.mid?PHPSESSID=c939116b08b23cbe325f61acaad562f0 http://www.virtualsheetmusic.com/MIDI/Albinoni/AlbinoniOb3/02Adagio.mid?PHPSESSID=c939116b08b23cbe325f61acaad562f0 http://www.virtualsheetmusic.com/MIDI/Albinoni/AlbinoniOb3/03Allegro.mid?PHPSESSID=c939116b08b23cbe325f61acaad562f0 Classical archives is a great classical midi site. You can use it mostly free but you have to create a logon password, and you are only allowed 5 downloads per day. That seems to be a small penalty to use it FREE! Worst come to worse, create a 2nd password using an alternate email address and password. http://www.classicalarchives.com/main/a.html#ALBINONI There are tons of midi files, you just have to look around! Max Arwood ----- Original Message ----- From: "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> Newsgroups: cakewalk.audio Sent: Thursday, April 10, 2008 10:13 PM Subject: App that seperates audio > There was an app that allowed for seperating and > editing chords by somehow extracting notes form > chords. I'm wondering if it will do the same with > instruments and allow say to substitute one instrument > for another ... > > I posted about 'sad and joyful music'. It was Albinoni > Oboe concertos. I'd like to replace the violin in one > with a viola and the flutes in another with horn. > > It would be so cool to hear them over and over with > different instrumentation. > > Doesn't "Audition" by Adobe claim to do something > similar? > > Thans : -) > > "AKA gray asphalt" <benvhoff(a)gmail.com> wrote in message news:RIALj.30420$6J3.6791(a)newsfe13.phx... > There was an app that allowed for seperating and > editing chords by somehow extracting notes form > chords. I'm wondering if it will do the same with > instruments and allow say to substitute one instrument > for another ... > > I posted about 'sad and joyful music'. It was Albinoni > Oboe concertos. I'd like to replace the violin in one > with a viola and the flutes in another with horn. > > It would be so cool to hear them over and over with > different instrumentation. > > Doesn't "Audition" by Adobe claim to do something > similar? > > Thans : -) > >
From: Ricky Hunt on 11 Apr 2008 12:37
"Michael" <muirheadNOm(a)MOREshawSPAM.ca> wrote in message news:vEDLj.40774$rd2.16703(a)pd7urf3no... > > You'd better be starting from pretty friggin' fine-quality compressed > audio if you're after decent per-instrument audio extraction from it (when > it's possible - and that isn't far ahead at all). I'm not so sure about that. I've found that for most non-classical music lower bitrate MP3's (128kbps) sound better to me in the car (even better than the real CD in some cases). It gives it much more presence and helps get the "important parts" above the noise floor of the car interior due to the fact that it throws away "lesser" parts and brings the important stuff up front. This could be a plus for a program trying to pick out the major parts of the song without getting thrown off by things that might not matter that much. |