From: Mark on

> > hey look at that!
> > the MP3 got rid of all the hiss   :-)
>
> I wish.
>
> Audible hiss is usually above -60 dB, and down in the 4 KHz range where the
> ear is most sensitive.
>
> IME, a 256K MP3 pretty well preserves low level detail down into the -60 dB
> range, so its not going to remove audible hiss, and its not going to producw
> a spectrogram  with appreciable visible changes due to the removal of
> low-level detail.-

Arnie... I fully agree, I was just trying to be funny...

I have tried A/B comparisons several times and I have not ever heard
any difference between an original and a 256K MP3.

At 128K they can get swishy...

Mark





From: Scott Dorsey on
Mark <makolber(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>I have tried A/B comparisons several times and I have not ever heard
>any difference between an original and a 256K MP3.

Listen for stereo imaging changes. If you have a good speaker system that
actually images properly, it is very interesting to hear what the encoder
does to the stereo field. Stuff starts moving around.

>At 128K they can get swishy...

Yes, that's when it starts to get _really_ nasty.
--scott
--
"C'est un Nagra. C'est suisse, et tres, tres precis."