From: measekite on
Many people (not only Canon users) use a point and shoot of sorts
(including EVF Long Zooms and Compacts) as well as a DSLR. Many use the
same brand. So it appears that Canon made a good decision to change the
new Xsi from a CF card to an SD card.

I am not sure but I do not think there is any advantage to a CF card and
the SD is less costly.

As long as there is not advantage I am wondering if Canon, on the new
rev of new DSLR version, is going to change all DSLRs to the SD format.
So far I think that would be a good idea.

Any opinions?
From: Rudy Benner on

"measekite" <inkystinky(a)oem.com> wrote in message
news:rJtTj.1653$nW2.648(a)nlpi064.nbdc.sbc.com...
> Many people (not only Canon users) use a point and shoot of sorts
> (including EVF Long Zooms and Compacts) as well as a DSLR. Many use the
> same brand. So it appears that Canon made a good decision to change the
> new Xsi from a CF card to an SD card.
>
> I am not sure but I do not think there is any advantage to a CF card and
> the SD is less costly.
>
> As long as there is not advantage I am wondering if Canon, on the new rev
> of new DSLR version, is going to change all DSLRs to the SD format. So
> far I think that would be a good idea.
>
> Any opinions?

My older Nikon D-50 uses a SD card while my newer Nikon D-200 uses a CF
card.

From: David J Taylor on
Rudy Benner wrote:
> "measekite" <inkystinky(a)oem.com> wrote in message
> news:rJtTj.1653$nW2.648(a)nlpi064.nbdc.sbc.com...
>> Many people (not only Canon users) use a point and shoot of sorts
>> (including EVF Long Zooms and Compacts) as well as a DSLR. Many use
>> the same brand. So it appears that Canon made a good decision to
>> change the new Xsi from a CF card to an SD card.
>>
>> I am not sure but I do not think there is any advantage to a CF card
>> and the SD is less costly.
>>
>> As long as there is not advantage I am wondering if Canon, on the
>> new rev of new DSLR version, is going to change all DSLRs to the SD
>> format. So far I think that would be a good idea.
>>
>> Any opinions?
>
> My older Nikon D-50 uses a SD card while my newer Nikon D-200 uses a
> CF card.

There may be a feeling in some pro circles that CF is better simply
because it is physically bigger. It may also be slightly ahead in
capacity and speed. Though SD cards have, I believe, the better
connection mechanism. For the non-pros, I think that SD is clearly the
standard today. Tomorrow, who knows?

Cheers,
David


From: David J Taylor on
Pete D wrote:
> "David J Taylor"
> <david-taylor(a)blueyonder.neither-this-bit.nor-this-bit.co.uk> wrote in
> message news:dByTj.19923$yD2.10642(a)text.news.virginmedia.com...
>> Rudy Benner wrote:
>>> "measekite" <inkystinky(a)oem.com> wrote in message
>>> news:rJtTj.1653$nW2.648(a)nlpi064.nbdc.sbc.com...
>>>> Many people (not only Canon users) use a point and shoot of sorts
>>>> (including EVF Long Zooms and Compacts) as well as a DSLR. Many
>>>> use the same brand. So it appears that Canon made a good decision
>>>> to change the new Xsi from a CF card to an SD card.
>>>>
>>>> I am not sure but I do not think there is any advantage to a CF
>>>> card and the SD is less costly.
>>>>
>>>> As long as there is not advantage I am wondering if Canon, on the
>>>> new rev of new DSLR version, is going to change all DSLRs to the SD
>>>> format. So far I think that would be a good idea.
>>>>
>>>> Any opinions?
>>>
>>> My older Nikon D-50 uses a SD card while my newer Nikon D-200 uses a
>>> CF card.
>>
>> There may be a feeling in some pro circles that CF is better simply
>> because it is physically bigger. It may also be slightly ahead in
>> capacity and speed. Though SD cards have, I believe, the better
>> connection mechanism. For the non-pros, I think that SD is clearly
>> the standard today. Tomorrow, who knows?
>>
>> Cheers,
>> David
>
> And doesn't the1DsMkII have both??

Smacks of indecision, doesn't it? <G>

David


From: virtuPIC on
> I am not sure but I do not think there is any advantage to a CF card and
> the SD is less costly.

I would expect that CF and SD cards use the same chips. Cannot tell
about electrical contacts and handling which is also a matter of
personal taste.

Actually, I prefer SD since they seem to become kind of industry
standard.

virtuPIC
--
Airspace V - international hangar flying!
tools & toys at http://www.airspace-v.com/ggadgets