From: Phillip Walters on
I have just opened a fairly large .avi file (934MB) in QT Pro and it
beachballed for about 15 secs before making it available to watch.
Opening the same file in VLC is almost instantaneous, this behaviour
seems to be the norm. Why the difference ? Is it because QT loads up the
whole file at once and VLC does it " on the fly" so to speak ? I have
noticed that dragging the onscreen timel slider works well in QT but
usually manages to bring up an error in VLC, although this error warning
can just be cancelled and it continues on its merry way.
--
Phil

http://www.philwalters.co.uk

From: Jaimie Vandenbergh on
On Sun, 29 Jun 2008 06:23:44 +0100, pjwalters(a)nospamdsl.pipex.com
(Phillip Walters) wrote:

>I have just opened a fairly large .avi file (934MB) in QT Pro and it
>beachballed for about 15 secs before making it available to watch.
>Opening the same file in VLC is almost instantaneous, this behaviour
>seems to be the norm. Why the difference ? Is it because QT loads up the
>whole file at once and VLC does it " on the fly" so to speak ?

Yep. VLC will also play partially-downloaded files, or ones with gaps
in, which QT Player usually won't.

VLC does this trick by not using the system decoders, but using its
own instead if it has one.

>I have
>noticed that dragging the onscreen timel slider works well in QT but
>usually manages to bring up an error in VLC, although this error warning
>can just be cancelled and it continues on its merry way.

VLC is a bit zealous with its error panel - why do I need to kmow
about three dropped frames when I've just skipped ten minutes of
movie? It does have a "don't bother me again" tickbox, but that only
lasts for that session.

Cheers - Jaimie
--
Those who live by the sword get shot by those who don't.
From: Phillip Walters on
Jaimie Vandenbergh <jaimie(a)sometimes.sessile.org> wrote:

> On Sun, 29 Jun 2008 06:23:44 +0100, pjwalters(a)nospamdsl.pipex.com
> (Phillip Walters) wrote:
>
> >I have just opened a fairly large .avi file (934MB) in QT Pro and it
> >beachballed for about 15 secs before making it available to watch.
> >Opening the same file in VLC is almost instantaneous, this behaviour
> >seems to be the norm. Why the difference ? Is it because QT loads up the
> >whole file at once and VLC does it " on the fly" so to speak ?
>
> Yep. VLC will also play partially-downloaded files, or ones with gaps
> in, which QT Player usually won't.
>
> VLC does this trick by not using the system decoders, but using its
> own instead if it has one.
>
> >I have
> >noticed that dragging the onscreen timel slider works well in QT but
> >usually manages to bring up an error in VLC, although this error warning
> >can just be cancelled and it continues on its merry way.
>
> VLC is a bit zealous with its error panel - why do I need to kmow
> about three dropped frames when I've just skipped ten minutes of
> movie? It does have a "don't bother me again" tickbox, but that only
> lasts for that session.
>
> Cheers - Jaimie

Thanks for the information.
--
Phil

http://www.philwalters.co.uk

From: Peter Ceresole on
Phillip Walters <pjwalters(a)nospamdsl.pipex.com> wrote:

> I have just opened a fairly large .avi file (934MB) in QT Pro and it
> beachballed for about 15 secs before making it available to watch.
> Opening the same file in VLC is almost instantaneous

Yes, I always open .avis in VLC and it works very well.

But my QTPro player won't display them at all. It says I need an extra
component, but sends me to a page that seems not to have anything
useful...

Since VLC works so well, I've never looked further. What's the extra
gizmo?
--
Peter
From: Phillip Walters on
Peter Ceresole <peter(a)cara.demon.co.uk> wrote:

> Phillip Walters <pjwalters(a)nospamdsl.pipex.com> wrote:
>
> > I have just opened a fairly large .avi file (934MB) in QT Pro and it
> > beachballed for about 15 secs before making it available to watch.
> > Opening the same file in VLC is almost instantaneous
>
> Yes, I always open .avis in VLC and it works very well.
>
> But my QTPro player won't display them at all. It says I need an extra
> component, but sends me to a page that seems not to have anything
> useful...
>
> Since VLC works so well, I've never looked further. What's the extra
> gizmo?

I have Perian installed, have you got that ?

--
Phil

http://www.philwalters.co.uk