From: terrydoc on
Users cannot connect to the applications but can PING the app servers
(10.10.10.130/134/135) - these are NATted - users see them as
192.168.0.42/37/35. Any suggestions on what the router debug output is
saying?

3725_Backup#
*Mar 1 00:11:12: %ISDN-6-CONNECT: Interface BRI1/0:1 is now connected
to xxxxxxx
3725_Backup# show ip nat trans
Pro Inside global Inside local Outside local Outside
global
--- 10.10.10.130 192.168.0.42 --- ---
--- 10.10.10.134 192.168.0.37 --- ---
--- 10.10.10.135 192.168.0.35 --- ---

3725_Backup#
**********************************************************************************
w client logon attempt

3725_Backup# debug ip packet detail
17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
SYN

17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
40, sending
17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
RST

17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
SYN

17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
40, sending
17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
RST

17:42:36: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
17:42:36: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
SYN

17:42:36: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
40, sending
17:42:36: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
RST
From: Thrill5 on
It's showing that the source IP 10.10.10.130 is attempting to connect to
10.10.10.135 on port 3200 (The SYN packet). The server then responds with a
RST packet, which indicates that no application is listening on port 3200.
The source and destination are all inside networks (all on the 10.10.10.x
network), so no NATing is being done

<terrydoc(a)o2.ie> wrote in message
news:a4e0e42a-3314-4837-836c-fce4053830ec(a)p25g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...
> Users cannot connect to the applications but can PING the app servers
> (10.10.10.130/134/135) - these are NATted - users see them as
> 192.168.0.42/37/35. Any suggestions on what the router debug output is
> saying?
>
> 3725_Backup#
> *Mar 1 00:11:12: %ISDN-6-CONNECT: Interface BRI1/0:1 is now connected
> to xxxxxxx
> 3725_Backup# show ip nat trans
> Pro Inside global Inside local Outside local Outside
> global
> --- 10.10.10.130 192.168.0.42 --- ---
> --- 10.10.10.134 192.168.0.37 --- ---
> --- 10.10.10.135 192.168.0.35 --- ---
>
> 3725_Backup#
> **********************************************************************************
> w client logon attempt
>
> 3725_Backup# debug ip packet detail
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
> 17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
> SYN
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
> 40, sending
> 17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
> RST
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
> 17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
> SYN
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
> 40, sending
> 17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
> RST
>
> 17:42:36: IP: s=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), d=10.10.10.135, len 48, rcvd 2
> 17:42:36: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
> SYN
>
> 17:42:36: IP: s=10.10.10.135 (local), d=10.10.10.130 (Dialer4), len
> 40, sending
> 17:42:36: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
> RST


From: terrydoc on
Thanks for the reply, I'm sorry as in my original post I had changed
some of the IP addresses and it appeared that the source and
destination are all in the same network - this is not the case - see
the correct debug output here. I know the client (10.0.18.35) can ping
the NATted addresses (10.0.0.130/134/135) - so NATting is working ok.
But when the client tries to access the application I get...
3725_Backup#
17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), d=10.0.0.135, len 48, rcvd 2
17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
SYN

17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.0.135 (local), d=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), len 40,
sending
17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
RST

17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), d=10.0.0.135, len 48, rcvd 2
17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
SYN

17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.0.135 (local), d=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), len 40,
sending
17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
RST
***************************************************************************************
Is it still the case that the app isn't listening on port 3200?


On Jun 24, 6:18 am, "Thrill5" <nos...(a)somewhere.com> wrote:
> It's showing that the source IP 10.10.10.130 is attempting to connect to
> 10.10.10.135 on port 3200 (The SYN packet). The server then responds with a
> RST packet, which indicates that no application is listening on port 3200.
> The source and destination are all inside networks (all on the 10.10.10.x
> network), so no NATing is being done
>
> <terry...(a)o2.ie> wrote in message
>
> news:a4e0e42a-3314-4837-836c-fce4053830ec(a)p25g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...
>
> > Users cannot connect to the applications but can PING the app servers
> > (10.10.10.130/134/135) - these are NATted - users see them as
> > 192.168.0.42/37/35. Any suggestions on what the router debug output is
> > saying?
>
From: terrydoc on
On Jun 24, 9:07 am, "terry...(a)o2.ie" <terry...(a)o2.ie> wrote:
> Thanks for the reply, I'm sorry as in my original post I had changed
> some of the IP addresses and it appeared that the source and
> destination are all in the same network - this is not the case - see
> the correct debug output here. I know the client (10.0.18.35) can ping
> the NATted addresses (10.0.0.130/134/135) - so NATting is working ok.
> But when the client tries to access the application I get...
> 3725_Backup#
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), d=10.0.0.135, len 48, rcvd 2
> 17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
> SYN
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.0.135 (local), d=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), len 40,
> sending
> 17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
> RST
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), d=10.0.0.135, len 48, rcvd 2
> 17:42:35: TCP src=2739, dst=3200, seq=3212891754, ack=0, win=32768
> SYN
>
> 17:42:35: IP: s=10.0.0.135 (local), d=10.0.18.35 (Dialer4), len 40,
> sending
> 17:42:35: TCP src=3200, dst=2739, seq=0, ack=3212891755, win=0 ACK
> RST
> ***************************************************************************************
> Is it still the case that the app isn't listening on port 3200?
>
> On Jun 24, 6:18 am, "Thrill5" <nos...(a)somewhere.com> wrote:
>
> > It's showing that the source IP 10.10.10.130 is attempting to connect to
> > 10.10.10.135 on port 3200 (The SYN packet). The server then responds with a
> > RST packet, which indicates that no application is listening on port 3200.
> > The source and destination are all inside networks (all on the 10.10.10.x
> > network), so no NATing is being done
>
> > <terry...(a)o2.ie> wrote in message
>
> >news:a4e0e42a-3314-4837-836c-fce4053830ec(a)p25g2000hsf.googlegroups.com...
>
> > > Users cannot connect to the applications but can PING the app servers
> > > (10.10.10.130/134/135) - these are NATted - users see them as
> > > 192.168.0.42/37/35. Any suggestions on what the router debug output is
> > > saying?

OK it is sorted... I had the Dialer interface on the router set up
without "ip nat outside". It is unusual though, as once the router has
the static NATs configured the router responds to the remote PING
requests even if the 3 server are plugged out of the network...