From: Franklin on
On Wed 23 Apr 2008 11:36:39, Bear Bottoms <bearbottoms1(a)gmai.com>
wrote:
> On Wed, 23 Apr 2008 02:53:30 -0500, Beryl
> <flyingterrapin(a)chillybits.org> wrote:
>
>>
>> It's sort of nice to have my CPU fan speed controlled, so I don't
>> need to hear a flat-out roaring fan all the time.
>
> Roaring? Actually the noise they make is rather benign.


Mr Bottoms, of course fans can make a significant noise. Nowadays they
are more often high rpm and make even more noise than ever especially
as cpu temps are so high.

Component or case fan, one with sleeve bearings sound ok to start with
then get progressively a lot noisier. And I just won't believe all
your fans were Pabst or equivalent.

http://www.silentpcreview.com/article63-page1.html


> I would
> think that constant speed changes would be more annoying.
> Besides, it is better for the electronics if it runs as it was
> designed to do.

There's nothing in the design of a PC which prevents use of thermal
controls. Low revving large blade fans are anything but annoying.


> As for a fan failing...I would hope you would notice.
>
> This is such a in-demand product, I'll just bet everyone is now
> rushing out to get one, lest they bake their machines. More
> likely, it itself would be the issue in the long run.
>

If you don't yet have the knowledge or ability to use SpeedFan then
leave it to others. There's no need to disrespect it or its users.


--

[ groups widened to comp.hardware ]