Prev: Regarding Digital NCO design
Next: Alternatives to CEVA, Tensilica and CoolFlux NXP
From: Andor on 24 Sep 2009 04:45
On 24 Sep., 09:49, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> >On Sep 23, 7:25 am, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> This is the result I get when I don't truncate w:
>
> ans =
>
>   Columns 1 through 9
>
>    -0.0903   -0.2708   -0.5417   -0.9028   -0.7292   -0.5208   -0.2778  
> -0.0000    0.2778
>
>   Columns 10 through 16
>
>     1.4583    2.7292    4.0903    5.5417    0.8333    0.5903    0.3125
>
> which is also wrong!

Your method is flawed alltogehter. In general, w will have infinite
length. Any truncation to use the FFT won't produce the expected
results. w can be found through long division of v2 by v1. This is
very simple to do with pencil and paper, the first couple of values in
w are

w = [1 0 0 0 -5 4 ...]

Regards,
Andor
From: Andor on 24 Sep 2009 05:00
On 24 Sep., 10:45, Andor <andor.bari...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> On 24 Sep., 09:49, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
>
>
>
>
> > >On Sep 23, 7:25 am, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> > This is the result I get when I don't truncate w:
>
> > ans =
>
> >   Columns 1 through 9
>
> >    -0.0903   -0.2708   -0.5417   -0.9028   -0.7292   -0.5208   -0.2778  
> > -0.0000    0.2778
>
> >   Columns 10 through 16
>
> >     1.4583    2.7292    4.0903    5.5417    0.8333    0.5903    0.3125
>
> > which is also wrong!
>
> Your method is flawed alltogehter. In general, w will have infinite
> length. Any truncation to use the FFT won't produce the expected
> results. w can be found through long division of v2 by v1. This is
> very simple to do with pencil and paper, the first couple of values in
> w are
>
> w = [1 0 0 0 -5 4 ...]

If you add 5 more terms yourself, I'll reveal the matlab one-liner
that calculates w to arbitrary length :-).
From: sofiyya on 24 Sep 2009 07:31
>On 24 Sep, 09:49, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>> >On Sep 23, 7:25 am, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> This is the result I get when I don't truncate w:
>>
>> ans =3D
>>
>> =A0 Columns 1 through 9
>>
>> =A0 =A0-0.0903 =A0 -0.2708 =A0 -0.5417 =A0 -0.9028 =A0 -0.7292 =A0
-0.520=
>8 =A0 -0.2778 =A0
>> -0.0000 =A0 =A00.2778
>>
>> =A0 Columns 10 through 16
>>
>> =A0 =A0 1.4583 =A0 =A02.7292 =A0 =A04.0903 =A0 =A05.5417 =A0 =A00.8333
=
>=A0 =A00.5903 =A0 =A00.3125
>>
>> which is also wrong!
>
>Once again: Are you sure the problem as stated has a solution?
>
>Rune
>

No, I'm not sure! But I didn't find explication for this! Maybe the
deconvolution is not a stable solution...
From: sofiyya on 24 Sep 2009 08:27
Thank you for your response,

Yes, with pencil and paper we can calculate w but it will be difficult for
a long vector, that's why I look for a methods to do it with matlab.. Maybe
it's impossible or maybe this depends on the coefficients of vect1 or
vect2.. I guess that we can't always find w / conv(w,vect1)=vect2;

>On 24 Sep., 10:45, Andor <andor.bari...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>> On 24 Sep., 09:49, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> > >On Sep 23, 7:25 am, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> > This is the result I get when I don't truncate w:
>>
>> > ans =3D
>>
>> > =A0 Columns 1 through 9
>>
>> > =A0 =A0-0.0903 =A0 -0.2708 =A0 -0.5417 =A0 -0.9028 =A0 -0.7292 =A0
-0.5=
>208 =A0 -0.2778 =A0
>> > -0.0000 =A0 =A00.2778
>>
>> > =A0 Columns 10 through 16
>>
>> > =A0 =A0 1.4583 =A0 =A02.7292 =A0 =A04.0903 =A0 =A05.5417 =A0
=A00.8333 =
>=A0 =A00.5903 =A0 =A00.3125
>>
>> > which is also wrong!
>>
>> Your method is flawed alltogehter. In general, w will have infinite
>> length. Any truncation to use the FFT won't produce the expected
>> results. w can be found through long division of v2 by v1. This is
>> very simple to do with pencil and paper, the first couple of values in
>> w are
>>
>> w =3D [1 0 0 0 -5 4 ...]
>
>If you add 5 more terms yourself, I'll reveal the matlab one-liner
>that calculates w to arbitrary length :-).
>
From: Andor on 24 Sep 2009 09:04
As I said, if you calculate 5 more terms in the w that I started
below, I will tell you how to calculate w (given v1 and v2) in Matlab
with one single command that has only 28 characters (challenge: who
can do it in less?).

:-)


On 24 Sep., 14:27, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> Thank you for your response,
>
> Yes, with pencil and paper we can calculate w but it will be difficult for
> a long vector, that's why I look for a methods to do it with matlab.. Maybe
> it's impossible or maybe this depends on the coefficients of vect1 or
> vect2.. I guess that we can't always find w / conv(w,vect1)=vect2;
>
>
>
>
>
> >On 24 Sep., 10:45, Andor <andor.bari...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> >> On 24 Sep., 09:49, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> >> > >On Sep 23, 7:25 am, "sofiyya" <karimae...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>
> >> > This is the result I get when I don't truncate w:
>
> >> > ans =3D
>
> >> > =A0 Columns 1 through 9
>
> >> > =A0 =A0-0.0903 =A0 -0.2708 =A0 -0.5417 =A0 -0.9028 =A0 -0.7292 =A0
> -0.5=
> >208 =A0 -0.2778 =A0
> >> > -0.0000 =A0 =A00.2778
>
> >> > =A0 Columns 10 through 16
>
> >> > =A0 =A0 1.4583 =A0 =A02.7292 =A0 =A04.0903 =A0 =A05.5417 =A0
> =A00.8333 =
> >=A0 =A00.5903 =A0 =A00.3125
>
> >> > which is also wrong!
>
> >> Your method is flawed alltogehter. In general, w will have infinite
> >> length. Any truncation to use the FFT won't produce the expected
> >> results. w can be found through long division of v2 by v1. This is
> >> very simple to do with pencil and paper, the first couple of values in
> >> w are
>
> >> w =3D [1 0 0 0 -5 4 ...]
>
> >If you add 5 more terms yourself, I'll reveal the matlab one-liner
> >that calculates w to arbitrary length :-).- Zitierten Text ausblenden -
>
> - Zitierten Text anzeigen -

First  |  Prev  |  Next  |  Last
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5
Prev: Regarding Digital NCO design
Next: Alternatives to CEVA, Tensilica and CoolFlux NXP