From: Bill Todd on
Jonathan Thornburg [remove -animal to reply] wrote:
> Morten Reistad wrote:
> | There is nothing barring us from making a laptop you can work on for
> | a day or so with normal battery cappactities. 6Ah @ 14V is about the
> | limit, or 84Wh. That means we would need to limit power for the system
> | to an average of 8W.
>
> Bill Todd <billtodd(a)metrocast.net> wrote:
>> I have no idea whether that's feasible or not, but what *does* seem
>> clear is that it's not at all 'normal': a quick review of the current
>> under-$1200 Thinkpads at the Lenovo site indicates that their standard
>> (6-cell, hence presumably nominally 11.1v.) batteries are rated 2.4 Ah,
>> or less than 27 Wh. Even if their optional 9-cell units actually
>> increase that by 50%, that's still less than half the number that you
>> quote above (and not the standard - 'normal' - part in any case).
>
> Thinkpad batteries come in multiple sizes; the ones I've met are 4.4,
> 6.6, and 7.2 amp-hours at 10.8 volts (= 47.5, 71.3, and 77.8 Watt-hours).

The fact that my old (570E) Thinkpad battery was only 2.6 Ah was the
reason I went to Lenovo's site to check what current battery capacities
were. The only ones for which Ah ratings were listed (for the sub-$1200
laptops that I skimmed) were the standard 6-cell, 2.4 Ah units. They
did mention optional 9-cell units which I'm sure were more robust, and I
certainly don't doubt your own experience - but Morton used the phrase
'normal battery capacities' and I took that to mean what one normally
gets (unless one specifies something else).

....

> There's presumably some room to increase battery capacity within a
> "tolerable" overall laptop-weight budget.

Perhaps - but that, too, would not be a 'normal' battery (at least by
today's standards).

- bill