E2K7 Send As issue
in [Microsoft Exchange]
|
From: Nicolas Macarez on 30 Dec 2007 05:25 I am running Exchange Server 2007 (not SP1) on W2K3 R2. I have two domains accepted: maindomain.com and otherdomain.com. The typical configuration for John Smith is to have smith(a)maindomain.com as his main and default e-mail address, and smith(a)otherdomain.com as another non-default e-mail address. When the user smith receives an e-mail sent to his alternate address smith(a)otherdomain.com, it is fine to answer AS smith(a)otherdomain.com: the mail flows away and gets to the recipients, no problem. But when he creates a new message from scratch and fills the field FROM with this non-default address smith(a)otherdomain.com, he gets this message: From: Microsoft Exchange Sent: Wednesday, September 26, 2007 9:03 AM To: Sender Subject: Undeliverable: Delivery has failed to these recipients or distribution lists: User smith(a)maindomain.com You are not allowed to send this message because you are trying to send on behalf of another sender without permission to do so. Please verify that you are sending on behalf of the correct sender, or ask your system administrator to help you get the required permission. Diagnostic information for administrators: Generating server: smith(a)maindomain.com #MSEXCH:MSExchangeIS:/DC=local/DC=maindomain:maindomain-EXCHANGE[578:0x000004DC:0x0000001D] #SMTP# And the message is not sent, of course. A workaround is to reply to a message previously sent to smith(a)otherdomain.com, and then to modify the recipient, subject, and so on. It works; the message is indeed sent AS smith(a)otherdomain.com. But I wonder if it's possible to do so with a brand new message. Any idea? Help appreciated. Nicolas
From: Rich Matheisen [MVP] on 30 Dec 2007 16:56 "Nicolas Macarez" <macarez(a)free.fr> wrote: >I am running Exchange Server 2007 (not SP1) on W2K3 R2. > >I have two domains accepted: maindomain.com and otherdomain.com. >The typical configuration for John Smith is to have smith(a)maindomain.com as >his main and default e-mail address, and smith(a)otherdomain.com as another >non-default e-mail address. > >When the user smith receives an e-mail sent to his alternate address >smith(a)otherdomain.com, it is fine to answer AS smith(a)otherdomain.com: the >mail flows away and gets to the recipients, no problem. But when he creates >a new message from scratch and fills the field FROM with this non-default >address smith(a)otherdomain.com, he gets this message: Does he have the "Send As" permission on the AD object with the SMTP proxy address smith(a)otherdomain.com? -- Rich Matheisen MCSE+I, Exchange MVP MS Exchange FAQ at http://www.swinc.com/resource/exch_faq.htm Don't send mail to this address mailto:h.pott(a)getronics.com Or to these, either: mailto:h.pott(a)pinkroccade.com mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)getronics.com mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)pinkroccade.com
From: Nicolas Macarez on 30 Dec 2007 18:50 "Rich Matheisen [MVP]" <richnews(a)rmcons.com.NOSPAM.COM> a �crit dans le message de news: ju4gn352vvq7tri02e84kvsd2it9anu8cn(a)4ax.com... > "Nicolas Macarez" <macarez(a)free.fr> wrote: > >>I am running Exchange Server 2007 (not SP1) on W2K3 R2. >> >>I have two domains accepted: maindomain.com and otherdomain.com. >>The typical configuration for John Smith is to have smith(a)maindomain.com >>as >>his main and default e-mail address, and smith(a)otherdomain.com as another >>non-default e-mail address. >> >>When the user smith receives an e-mail sent to his alternate address >>smith(a)otherdomain.com, it is fine to answer AS smith(a)otherdomain.com: the >>mail flows away and gets to the recipients, no problem. But when he >>creates >>a new message from scratch and fills the field FROM with this non-default >>address smith(a)otherdomain.com, he gets this message: > > Does he have the "Send As" permission on the AD object with the SMTP > proxy address smith(a)otherdomain.com? Rich, I did try to grant the "Send As" permission in ADUC by following this article http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa998291.aspx (the section for E2K7 RTM). But the issue is that you can indeed grant the permission to an object such as smith (username of John Smith) or another user, but not to a specific SMTP address (smith(a)otherdomain.com in my case). Where am I wrong? Best regards Nicolas > > -- > Rich Matheisen > MCSE+I, Exchange MVP > MS Exchange FAQ at http://www.swinc.com/resource/exch_faq.htm > Don't send mail to this address mailto:h.pott(a)getronics.com > Or to these, either: mailto:h.pott(a)pinkroccade.com > mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)getronics.com > mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)pinkroccade.com
From: Rich Matheisen [MVP] on 30 Dec 2007 23:47 "Nicolas Macarez" <macarez(a)free.fr> wrote: [ snip ] >Rich, >I did try to grant the "Send As" permission in ADUC by following this >article >http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa998291.aspx (the section for >E2K7 RTM). > >But the issue is that you can indeed grant the permission to an object such >as smith (username of John Smith) or another user, but not to a specific >SMTP address (smith(a)otherdomain.com in my case). > >Where am I wrong? By thinking that the SMTP address is independant of the AD object. Try here: http://ivasoft.com/choosefrom2007.shtml -- Rich Matheisen MCSE+I, Exchange MVP MS Exchange FAQ at http://www.swinc.com/resource/exch_faq.htm Don't send mail to this address mailto:h.pott(a)getronics.com Or to these, either: mailto:h.pott(a)pinkroccade.com mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)getronics.com mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)pinkroccade.com
From: Nicolas Macarez on 31 Dec 2007 03:14
"Rich Matheisen [MVP]" <richnews(a)rmcons.com.NOSPAM.COM> a �crit dans le message de news: lrsgn3t8rucg0udl8jbrch9i3mqopl3tc9(a)4ax.com... > "Nicolas Macarez" <macarez(a)free.fr> wrote: > > [ snip ] > >>Rich, >>I did try to grant the "Send As" permission in ADUC by following this >>article >>http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa998291.aspx (the section for >>E2K7 RTM). >> >>But the issue is that you can indeed grant the permission to an object >>such >>as smith (username of John Smith) or another user, but not to a specific >>SMTP address (smith(a)otherdomain.com in my case). >> >>Where am I wrong? > > By thinking that the SMTP address is independant of the AD object. > > Try here: > http://ivasoft.com/choosefrom2007.shtml Thanks. So it's by design in E2K7 and I need a third party software. I guess my client will stick to the workaround which consists in just replying to a previous mail sent by anyone to smith(a)otherdomain.com and changing the recipient, subject and content of the mail. Thanks for the help. Nicolas > > -- > Rich Matheisen > MCSE+I, Exchange MVP > MS Exchange FAQ at http://www.swinc.com/resource/exch_faq.htm > Don't send mail to this address mailto:h.pott(a)getronics.com > Or to these, either: mailto:h.pott(a)pinkroccade.com > mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)getronics.com > mailto:melvin.mcphucknuckle(a)pinkroccade.com |