From: Ofnuts on
On 14/07/2010 11:05, David J Taylor wrote:
> "SneakyP" <48umofa02(a)WHITELISTONLYsneakemail.com> wrote in message
> news:Xns9DB51DD82567448umofa02sneakemailc(a)127.0.0.1...
>> Looking for recomendations on stepping up from that horrid 18-55mm
>> zoom kit
>> lens in a Canon to a decent zoom lens for a sharper picture. Problem is,
>> what is the better option? Get the Lens that has a quality of acceptable
>> sharpness in that particular camera body, or get the camera with better
>> sensor capabilities?
>>
>> My strategy was to always go with investing in lenses first, before even
>> having a looksee at what else is there to buy in a camera body.
>>
>> I use the Canon Rebel XS, so my range may be limited, but I still want to
>> have upwards mobility for the lenses. IOW - is that sharpness the best I
>> can expect from this camera body, or does it get ridiculously steeper in
>> price as a better zoom lens is found?
>>
>>
>>
>> --
>> SneakyP
>> To email me, you know what to do.
>
> Some people feel that Nikon offers better value in medium priced lenses
> than Canon - Nikon don't have a two-tier quality system as Canon does
> with its "L" lenses.
>
> Having said that, I had thought that Canon's current "kit" lens was
> supposed to be much improved on its earlier version.

The XS (aka 1000D) comes with the previous generation kit lens, that has
no IS, and is optically not so good.

But even good kit lenses such as the 18-55 IS are kit lenses, and I've
added some decent lenses to my XSi (including the Canon 100mm macro)
that clearly improved the results.

--
Bertrand
From: Ofnuts on
On 14/07/2010 14:21, eatmorepies wrote:

> The lenses will be with you for ever, save up and buy L.

That was true for non-IS lenses, but I hear that the IS lenses
eventually wear out and cannot be repaired.

--
Bertrand
From: Wolfgang Weisselberg on
Ofnuts <o.f.n.u.t.s(a)la.poste.net> wrote:
> On 14/07/2010 14:21, eatmorepies wrote:

>> The lenses will be with you for ever, save up and buy L.

> That was true for non-IS lenses, but I hear that the IS lenses
> eventually wear out and cannot be repaired.

Source?

-Wolfgang
From: Wolfgang Weisselberg on
SneakyP <48umofa02(a)WHITELISTONLYsneakemail.com> wrote:
> Looking for recomendations on stepping up from that horrid 18-55mm zoom kit
> lens in a Canon to a decent zoom lens for a sharper picture.

18-55mm IS. Should be cheap and better.
Though a fixed focal length lens is often better and cheaper
than the zoom.

> Problem is,
> what is the better option? Get the Lens that has a quality of acceptable
> sharpness in that particular camera body, or get the camera with better
> sensor capabilities?

Lens.

> I use the Canon Rebel XS, so my range may be limited, but I still want to
> have upwards mobility for the lenses.

You can use all EF and EF-S lenses, no limitations apply,
same as any other crop sensor camera since the 20D.

If you plan to go full format one day, you probably want EF
and not EF-S.

-Wolfgang
From: Ofnuts on
On 16/07/2010 01:37, Wolfgang Weisselberg wrote:
> Ofnuts<o.f.n.u.t.s(a)la.poste.net> wrote:
>> On 14/07/2010 14:21, eatmorepies wrote:
>
>>> The lenses will be with you for ever, save up and buy L.
>
>> That was true for non-IS lenses, but I hear that the IS lenses
>> eventually wear out and cannot be repaired.
>
> Source?

Soemwhere in www.eos-numerique.com
--
Bertrand